Early Contacts between Christianity and Islam

Staff Writer

Table of Contents

Christianity and Islam have always been two noxious bedfellows and yet always proclaim and wish peace on earth. It would not be a crass assumption to state that the two religions have over the centuries crossed paths and re-crossed paths many times. Crossing paths might have been in their ideologies, conflicts, doctrinal interpretations and even sharing some physical spaces. Therefore, in this brief writing, we will explore the early contacts between Christianity and Islam and see how they have influenced each other.

Early Contacts between Christianity and Islam

The early contacts between Christianity and Islam were not short of frames. According to Kaufman et al., “frames are cognitive shortcuts that people use to help make sense of complex information.” They are means of interpreting our world and perhaps, the world of other people around us. Such interpretations helped them to see things the way they thought best and restructure the things that were not properly set as they thought. The polemics between the two religions hinging majorly on their understanding of the nature of God (one considers it a Tawhid and the other, a Trinity) “created mutually incompatible interpretations” of concepts of monotheism. The early contacts between the two religions were not only unique, but they were also replete with political and ideological affronts. According to Goddard:

Christian-Muslim relations over the centuries have developed on a kind of layer-by-layer basis: what happened in one community in one generation produced a reaction in the other community which in turn contributed to the development of formulations and attitudes in the first community in later generations. 

Briefly, I will describe two such early contacts that underline the Christian-Muslim relationships. They are the contacts with Monk Bahira and Monophysite Christians of the Axum kingdom. 

Monk Bahira

It is claimed that the first Christian contact with the prophet Muhammad was the oft-repeated monk Bahira. According to Daniel, monk Bahira saw in the Prophet while a boy, a messenger of God to be. Therefore, he warned the prophet’s uncle, Abu Talib:

That they should serve him and take care of him because he would become a prophet and the lord of a great people, and that they should immediately protect him from the Jews, for the time would come when these would want to kill him because he was going to say things contrary to the Law of the Jews.

The account rendered by Bahira was nothing different from Jesus’ nativity narration. It was like the message from the angel Gabriel to Joseph in a dream, who was warned to take the child Jesus and mother and depart to Egypt (Matthew 2:13). Goddard would describe such as a kind of biographical parallelism, that is, showing a striking similarity between prophet Muhammad’s boyhood account and Jesus’. Such an association could be considered a historical topos.

The Migration to Axum Kingdom

Early contact between the two religions can also be likened to the first Muslims’ reactions to the persecution in Makkah. They migrated in 615 A.D. to the kingdom of Axum (that is, an ancient town in northern Ethiopia in the 1st to 6th century A.D. Historically, the town was known as Abyssinia).

It was a Christian kingdom that adhered to the Monophysite's understanding of Christianity. That is, they believed that Jesus has one true nature which is primarily divine with attributes.

It could be argued that the choice of Christian Monophysites coincided with the Islamic concept of the nature of Jesus. Also, it supports the account reported by Ibn Ishaq that there was a Christian Monophysite delegation from the town of Najran, in South Arabia to Medina in 622 A.D to dialogue with prophet Muhammad.

One can imagine the early contacts and dialogues that had existed between the two religions were both regional and cultural as well as tactical, and open-minded.

The “new Muslims”, that is, converts from Arabian paganism in Makkah sought solace in Axum as the Christians of Najran, in South Arabia sent a delegation to prophet Muhammad in Madina for dialogue. Critics would argue that the association with the Monophysites could be interpreted as a ‘cognitive shortcut to understanding a Christian sect’s concept of Christology, and in fact, monotheism rather than the orthodox Christian’s concept of Christology and monotheism.  

Finally, it could be said that Islam sought dialogue not with the whole of Christianity but with a particular sect (Monophysite Christianity whose Christology was condemned at the Council of Chalcedon 451) and from a particular region. From this point, both religions framed and reframed their and each other’s ideologies.

Sources

S. Kaufman, M. Elliot, D. Shmueli, (2014) “Frames, Framing and Reframing”. https://www.beyondintractability.org/

H. Goddard (2000) A History of Christian-Muslim Relations. Edinburgh University Press.

N. Daniel (2003) Islam and the West: The Making of an Image. OneWorld, Oxford.

H. Goddard (1998) Christians and Muslims: from double standards to mutual understanding. Curzon Press, Surrey.

S.S. Nadwi (2004) Sirat-un-Nabi: The life of the Prophet, rendered into English by Mohd. Saeed Siddiqi, vol. 3, Kitabbhavan, New Delhi-India.

Ibn Kathir (2006) The life of the Prophet Muhammad, vol. 1, Al-Sira al-Nabawiyya, translated by Trevor Le Gassick, Garnet Publishing, Uk. 

Comments

The doubting writer said…
Christianity and Islam are two religions that have existed side by side for many centuries. They have the same roots, a common history, but different interpretations. Unfortunately, there are many examples of the irreconcilability of Christians and Muslims in history, but you can also find opposite examples. After all, one of the foundations of both religions is humility and love for one's neighbor. Thank you for the in-depth article.
March 10, 2021 at 4:10 PM
iPostthisweek said…
Thanks, Elena for your comments.
March 10, 2021 at 6:10 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Connection between a Personal Name and Name Groups in Shawnee Social Organisation

Staff Writer
Table of Contents Shawnee People The Divisions The Name Groups and Personal Names I’m always attracted to and interested in the culturally distinct and characteristic elements of different traditions or societies. Reading about the Shawnee people of Native American tribes is no different. I immediately fell in love with the linkage between Shawnee name groups and personal names. The name groups seem to present the Shawnee as a one-descent group with five major divisions. To examine this connection between a personal name and name group, a brief description of Shawnee will help in understanding the Shawnee social organisation. Shawnee People The term ‘Shawnee’ written in different forms ( Shaawanwaki, Shaawanowi lenaweeki, and Shawano ) is Algonquian like the archaic term ‘ shaawanwa ’ meaning ‘south.’ Thus, the term ‘Shawnee’ is (pronounced shaw-nee ) meaning the ‘southern people.’ The Shawnees are categorised as Algonquian-speaking North American Indian people whose pristine ho
Continue reading »

The Akamba – Concept of the Supreme Being & Totems

Staff Writer
Table of Contents Supreme Being (Worships and Venerations) Mulungu   Mumbi  Mwatuangi  Ngai  Asa  Ancestors Totems Here is a brief account of the religious beliefs of the Akamba. Spanning through Central Bantu, the Akamba ethnic group is estimated to be about 4.4 million people and occupies Southeastern Kenya in areas, such as Kangundo, Kibwezi, Kitui, Machakos, Makueni and Mwingi Districts and the Ukamba. A swathe of the Akamba population can also be found in the Mazeras and Kwale Districts of the Coast Province in Shiba Hills. The Akamba languages are Kikamba and Swahili. Globally, the Akamba are not exclusively a Kenyan or African tribe. They can be found in Uganda, Tanzania, and Paraguay, which makes it partly an indigenous group and partly an autochthonal group. Argument from migration theory suggests that Akamba came from Kilimanjaro (a word that means ‘mountain of whiteness’), basing their arguments on the similarity of certain cultural features with the Wachagga people of Kili
Continue reading »

Begrudging & Infightings: Aztec’s Theogony & Cosmogony

Staff Writer
Table of Contents Tezcatlipoca Quetzalcoatl Tlaloc Chalchiuhtlicue Nanauatzin Cosmic Order – The Balance Aztec is a name used to describe the Nahuatl-speaking people who thrived in central Mexico circa the 14 th  and 16 th  centuries as an empire and dominated large parts of Mesoamerica. Variously, the Aztecs had different names. They are known as Aztlan (which means ‘White Land’), the Tenochca (a name adopted from one of their ancestors called Tenoch), and the Mexica, which was a derivative from Metzliapan (which stands for ‘Moon Lake’). Ancient Aztec religious beliefs and practices were tied to their understanding of the world; the people were deeply amazed by the thought of the unknown, the universe and the end of time. These thoughts arouse some curiosity and awareness to understand better their world and how it came about. I used the term ‘theogony’ to describe the Aztecs’ generations of gods however, not in the context of Greek mythology where the ‘primordial deities’ were the fi
Continue reading »

President Biden’s Age is now the problem! Where’s the ADA?

Staff Writer
After the first US presidential debate, and the slow start of the incumbent, President Joe Biden, the democrats lost their minds. The democrats started to play with the acronym “SCAMPER.” They wanted a ‘substitute.’ They felt like ‘combining’ forces. They sort to make some ‘adaptations’ in their campaign strategy. They ‘modify’ the President’s schedules and so on. They wanted to ‘put into another use’ some tactics and styles. They outrightly wanted to ‘eliminate’ the President’s candidacy in the bid to ‘rearrange’ the campaign strategy to win the election come November 2024. Are you sure about that? Why all these jostles, sniffing and gossips? His crime is that he is 81 years old. They fear that he will lose them the presidency to an opponent whom the law has christened felon, the supreme court anointed a king through their presidential immunity verdict, and most Americans consider a venal potentate should he be re-elected as the president. I believe the people who criticize Mr. Bi
Continue reading »

The creator god, Tirawa - the Pawnee of the Native American Tribe

Staff Writer
Table of Contents The Pawnee The Holy Corn Tirawa and the Stars Culture of the Stars The religious beliefs of the Pawnee Native American tribe stand out as practices that are primarily Astro-theological and astronomical. As such they use or interpret the laws or culture of the stars to determine when it was safe to plant corn. Accurate calculation of these laws or cultures means a better harvest for the people. They were possible because Tirawa was their causer, teacher, and sustainer.   Corn is an essential crop that is not only a means of subsistence living for the Pawnee, but it is also a symbolic mother through her, and with her, the sun goddess, Shakuru blesses the people. The Pawnee The Pawnee are a North American Indian tribe who originally lived in Nebraska and northern Kansas before finally settling in today’s Oklahoma. Linguistically, they belong to the Caddoan family and call themselves the Chatiks si chatiks , meaning “Men of Men.” As with many Native American India
Continue reading »

Nigeria’s Pledge Vs the President’s Mandate: An Antithesis of Patriotism

Staff Writer
Table of Contents Nigeria’s Pledge The President’s Mandate Loyalty to the President or the Constitution? In recent years, the Nigerian polity has been bedeviled by one general term, ‘mandate.’ As years passed, the term mandate gained more ground and replaced the allegiance or any public or private declaration of loyalty to Nigeria, as a country. The contract the people signed with the country was gradually torn into bits by the politicians (or leaders) and by extension, the citizens, (and foreigners living in Nigeria). The current political and economic climate of Nigeria is the main reason for this article. The people have openly rejected Nigeria’s Pledge and have taken recourse to different political mandates of some politicians. The aim here is to bring to the fore the salient points of Nigeria’s Pledge against the mandate of the president. Nigeria’s Pledge The clear and concise words of Professor Felicia Adebola Adedoyin in 1976 describing the terms of the Nigerian oath of
Continue reading »

The Gi-ant of Africa and the goddess, Nemesis

Staff Writer
Image
Overview Nigeria is popularly known as the giant of Africa perhaps because of its population estimated at over 250 million people. It is a country with the largest concentration of black people in the entire world. In her halcyon days, the oil boom of the 1970s, with an unparallel rapid revenue expansion, peace and happiness, Nigeria began to enjoy the reputation as epitomized in the statement by the erstwhile Head of State, General Yakubu Gowon: “Money is not Nigeria’s problem. But how to spend it.” Such a statement was reflected in their leaders’ behaviours and thinking. From the 1970s to 2024, Nigeria’s leaders have not shifted from such mindsets. Both her military and civilian leaders continue to entertain careless, unaccountable, and foolish behaviours that brought a jinx upon the nation. The oil boom became a curse to the people by the Nigerian goddess called Gi-ant .   Gi-ant stands for “government issues – accountability, nepotism, thievery.” These are the three manifes
Continue reading »

The Weyekin in Nez Percé Tribe and Catholic Angels

Staff Writer
Table of Contents The Nez Percé People Catholic Teachings on Angels The Spirit, Weyekin in Nez Percé Tribe This writing is to briefly identify and recognize some cultural values of the Nez Percé tribe, especially their belief in Weyekin, often described as a personal guiding angel. The concept of a guiding angel provokes Catholic teachings about angels and comparison with the Nez Percé Weyekin, as the guiding spirit. But that will be a new piece of writing for the future. There can be a cross-cultural gleaning of ideas from nature, beliefs, and interactions.     The Nez Percé People The term Nez Percé, meaning “pierced nose” is the French coinage to describe the Nimiipuu tribe. The term Nimiipuu, meaning “we, the people” is a name the tribe used for themselves and their language, a part of the Sahaptin family. Early contacts with the Europeans, especially French explorers made the name Nez Percé popular because they unfairly adopted the name Nez Percé and used it for the Nimiipuu and n
Continue reading »

The Conflict between the Deities (Igwe and Amadioha) in Igbo Mythology over a Heat Wave

Staff Writer
Table of Contents Introduction The Deity – Igwe The Deity – Amadioha The Conflict between Igwe and Amadioha Introduction The current heat wave reminds me of the conflict between two Igbo deities, namely: Igwe and Amadioha. Just as it was noted somewhere in this blog: Nigeria's Diversity and the South-East/South-South Peripheral Inclusions: Biafra's Raison d'etre , November 15, 2021, the Igbo people are the third-largest ethnic group who live in southeastern Nigeria. They have a very rich culture and tradition among which is their concept of God which varies from one community to another but essentially, they believe that the gods guide and control their life and affairs in many ways. The Igbo concept of God stems from the idea of a chief god who creates everything. This god is supreme. The Igbo variously call this god Olisa bu uwa (the god who carries the world), Olisa bini Igwe , (the god who lives in the sky), Chukwu (the great god), or Chineke (the god who creates
Continue reading »